The tone of this story is more mythic than others we have read. Rushdie uses elements of myth, but always self-consciously or winkingly. At least the ending of this story is mythic with Shaila the narrator beginning a quest after hearing the voices of her family: "I do not know which direction I will take. I dropped the package on a park bench and started walking" (108). The whole story seems to happen for the reader through a haze of grief, and maybe the mythic tone is suitable because grief is anti-rational.
This story is also notable because it shows alienation from family life in a way other stories we've read never do. Shaila's husband and children die, and upon returning home her mother offers no consolation. Shaila does however find some support from the larger Indian community living in Canada, like Dr. Ranganathan. So unlike the claustrophobic world of a single family, like in Rushdie and Roy, Mukherjee portrays a single woman among a community. At the same time, Shaila doesn't really feel a connection with most of those people besides the fact that they share a homeland or lost family-members in a crash. Shaila is more alone than other protagonists we've read about.
Lang College, Spring 2011, group forum for daily readers' responses and links, media, etc.
READ THIS: PRESENTATIONS
PRESENTATIONS: please take these seriously: they are an important part of your participation in the class. Your job when you present is to lead the discussion on the reading for that day. You may bring in some research, but most of all, you should be very well-prepared with insights, interpretations, and questions about the reading at hand. You may want to begin by summarizing the progress of the plot represented by the excerpt assigned on that day. Then you should have passages picked out for the class to discuss. You may want to be ready, also, with the posts for the day (you can copy and paste them and print them out). The purpose of the presentation is to give more responsibility to the classmembers and de-center the discussion a little bit (although I will still chime in). Here are your assignments, mostly random. 1. Wed. 3/30 Small Things, 84-147, Eidia. 2. 4/4 Small Things, 148-225, Hannah. 3. 4/6 Small Things, ending, Anna. 4. 4/11 Ondaatje, Dan. 5. 4/13 Mukherjee, Michael. 6. 4/18 Poppies, 3-87, Karol. 7. 4/20 Poppies, 88-156, Jason. 8. 4/25 Poppies, 157-226, Joe. 9. 4/27, Poppies, 227-342, Will. 10. 5/2 Poppies, 343-446, Rachel. 11. 5/4 Poppies, finish, Jane.
No comments:
Post a Comment